Trolley Stop Inn: A Family-Friendly Pizza Pub Experience in Bethel Park

Staying in the area and riding the Montour Trail. Decided to give it a try. They weren’t kidding when they said they had the best meatballs! Wow! I had the Meatball Casserole and it was fantastic! My fiancé had the Trolley Stopper sandwich with turkey and that was also incredible! Highly recommend!

We just rented the event space for our son's graduation party. We had the most wonderful experience . Beautiful space, great service and food. Booking with Hailey was amazing and easy, great communication , Jessie , Sharon and Rich did an awesome job at serving drinks, food and everything else. Higly recommend and will book again! Thank you guys for an amazing evening!

Food is so good. I get the French Dip and get a side of Mac and cheese, which is quite literally the best Mac and cheese that I have ever had. And it is a big portion, too. The steak quesadilla is great, the Reuben is delicious and the coleslaw is incredible. I order from here around once a month or so. I had one issue with a forgotten drink a few months ago, but they fixed it right away and sent one out with no problem. They are always very nice when they bring my delivery. This is my go-to place.

We had a great lunch here, with leftovers for later! Note: unlike what some other places are doing due to inflation they don't add a sneaky credit card surcharge, the receipt before tax matches what is on the menu, but they do offer a small cash discount.

Went today for brunch buffet, $23.  Really nice variety, replenished often & very tasty! Standouts were the pork carnitas, crispy bacon, made to order omelets and generous mimosas for $6.

On Dec 29 dined inside and had the House Special "MeatloafMonday" and was speechless. The portion size of the dish blew me away for the price I paid, I was so excited to have enough food to drown my hunger. The 2 thick slices of tender, savory Meatloaf out did any meatloaf I have ever had with the nostalgia of a home cooked meal in your warm home after a cold day out in the snow. The mashed potatos were fluffy and melted in my mouth with the bold flavor of the gravy providing the extra bond of love between the ingredients including the crispy onion rings adorning the dish. I appreciate Maddie for a wonderful and enriching experience during my time there as she showcased hospitality worthy of a high value establishment.

Atmosphere is dated needing upgrade. Food is typical bar food fare. Casual dining. I was not a fan of the fries or onion rings. This review is definitely for your establishment. I was seated near the children's arcade/fun room. The chairs are deep black in color and so are the bench seats. It is better than prior to your water issues. Service was slow and your outside seating is nice. The interior is definitely in need of some updates.

We had a celebration of life luncheon for my mom 9/12/2025 at their new banquet venue - The Trolley Trackside Event space. The menu is varied enough that you'll find something you want for a large group. Rich Wolfe was fantastic to work with. He guided me through decision making (thank you!). The food was fantastic. Hot foods were hot and cold foods were cold. He and Cathy were so helpful during the luncheon. Our bartender (sorry, I don't know her name) was awesome! I know they're just getting started with these larger gatherings, but they handled everything as if they had been at it for years! Thank you to all of the staff at the Trolley Stop for making this a successful event to remember.